0 Reviews
MSRP:
$682.44
Used Price:
$682.44
Sale Price:
$758.27
From $1,122.99
Want to Sell Your Gun?
Want to Sell Your Gun?
In 2025 a new or used Colt Mustang Plus value varies depending on supply and demand. In the last 12 months there is great demand for a Colt Mustang Plus and most handguns. The Price for a Colt Mustang Plus has increased in cost by $0.00 in 2025 compared to 2024.
Estimated New and Used Values for a Colt Mustang Plus Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors.
| Condition | Trade-In | Private Party | Dealer |
|---|---|---|---|
| New In box | $492.88 | $644.53 | $758.27 |
| Excellent | $454.96 | $606.62 | $682.44 |
| Very Good | $417.05 | $606.62 | $682.44 |
| Good | $379.14 | $568.70 | $644.53 |
| Fair | $265.39 | $492.88 | $606.62 |
| Poor | $189.57 | $379.14 | N/A |
Gun Value Conditions explained:
New in box - 100% condition in unopened box. Excellent - 95%+ condition with or without box.
Very Good - 90% - 95% condition (all parts/finish should be original).
Good - 80-90% condition (all parts/finish should be original).
Fair - 30% - 80% condition, parts, and finish may or may not be original. Must function properly and shoot.
Poor - under 30% condition. Firearm has severe wear and tear, does not function, or is damaged.
Quick Cash Offer
We make you an quick cash offer online
We find the dealer that offers you the most money
Get cash for your gun or do a trade in
How We Compare to Selling It Yourself
We take all the hassle out of selling your gun.
Save Time
Quick Cash Offer
Get your cash offer in minutes
Selling it Yourself
Can take months to sell your gun privately
Buyer
Quick Cash Offer
Trusted retailers will pay you for your gun
Selling it Yourself
You don't know who you're selling to, or if they'll rip you off
Price
Quick Cash Offer
I'ts totally free to get a cash offer on your gun
Selling it Yourself
It costs money to place ads to sell your gun, and it takes a lot of time
Difficulty
Quick Cash Offer
Easy online paperwork and registration process for your safe and legal payout
Selling it Yourself
You have to trust the buyer to pay you, and trust that you're following the law
